What Have We Dunoon?
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Support
  • Contact

Why don't you knock it down and start over?

8/30/2019

55 Comments

 
Why don't you knock it down and start over?

This is a question Cal and I get A LOT.

To be honest, it's not a bad question. Even our structural engineer, who has been a fantastic help on the project, recommended we knock Jameswood down - THREE TIMES, in the same report! The Argyll and Bute council have taken the same stance on the place, recommending we demolish in nearly every meeting we have had with them face to face.



Picture
Our friend Barry, checking out Jameswood Villa with Cal, for the very first time. What have we Dunoon?
So why didn't we?

I want to start off by saying that we respect the opinions of these professionals. Cal and I don't have previous experience doing up a house. In every task we've done on the house so far, we've relied on the opinions and advice of professionals - whether it was for drainage, stonemasonry or roofing, we try learning from others' experiences, taking their knowledge on board, and using it to do the tasks at hand as properly as we can.

There are a long list of reasons for why we didn't consider knocking Jameswood down, and putting a new build in her place. Let's start by addressing the concerns of our structural engineers and the council.

It was recommended Jameswood was knocked down, not because it wasn't possible to make the repairs needed to make the building safe for living, but because, based on their knowledge of these types of restorations, it would be more economically viable to put a new build in Jameswood's place.
Picture
The property was so overgrown it was hard to see Jameswood from the road.
We aren't naive to the fact that this restoration will be costly, but we are also well aware of the fact that this advice was based on the average developer's life circumstances, which are very different to our own.

This restoration will either take a LOT of time, or a LOT of money to pay tradesmen to carry out the work. With the amount of physical labour needed to carry out this build, Jameswood would cost way too much to restore if it wasn't a DIY project, and saving the building wouldn't be economically viable.

For the average adult, who has the prior responsibilities of a mortgage or rent, a job and possibly even children, putting everything aside to work full-time on restorations is not often an option. Cal and I's life circumstances are much different from the average adult. Before Jameswood, we were quite nomadic - working and skiing in the winters, and saving up for road trips and wild camping throughout Europe and Canada in the summers. We don't have much money, but we have plenty of time to commit to Jameswood. It almost seems like fate that we were brought together. We were in the perfect life-stage to drop everything, move into a tiny caravan on a building site, and dedicate a LOT of time and hard work into a restoration project.
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Photos from our Euro roadtrip, in which we wild camped for three months. A photo of our new caravan - very happy to have a clean, dry space to retire to at the end of days on site.


​Members of the council, as well as my father, both pointed out that even with doing the restoration ourselves, the margins on the project weren't large enough to justify the time it would take - we could quite easily make more money by working. I think this purely economic analysis of our decision overlooks some very important things this opportunity has presented us with. Jameswood gives us a fulfilling goal to work towards. It gives us an incredible experience to challenge ourselves and learn every single day - not just about house building, but about managing and taking responsibility for a team - with up to 10 volunteers at a time helping with the project. It's teaching us incredible problem solving skills, with unexpected challenges facing us every day. And importantly, it's teaching us, as a couple, how to work together as a team.
Picture
One of the amazing groups we hosted this summer for an experience exchange. We sheltered and fed our team, taught them new building skills and showed them our favourite spots in the area.

From the very start, Cal and I have wanted to make as environmentally responsible decisions as possible for this project. 

Architectural waste is a HUGELY overlooked aspect of our ever-growing landfill problems. Our society has be designed to disconnect consumers from the life cycle of the products they use. Items we buy are conveniently brought to our doorstep or displayed on shelves at nearby stores. At the end of their life, our waste is collected from our doorstep and taken away. Out of sight. Out of mind.

But where are the materials from a full demolition going? When a school in the Dunoon community was being demolished, we investigated. On site, you could see perfectly good timber flooring and joists being torn to shreds by huge machines, and stuck in skips to be taken off to the dump.

We acknowledged that a new build could present us with an opportunity to build a very efficient home in its place, but with Jameswood requiring gutting, we were presented with a great opportunity to achieve similar efficiency with an eco-retrofit. Even if we chose eco-friendly materials for a new build, the fact of the matter is that all materials take energy to make and transport. The embodied energy involved in retrofitting this Victorian building is a lot less than would be required for a full rebuild.

Reduce. Reuse. Recycle.

We were going to reuse Jameswood. In this case, we felt it was the most environmentally friendly option we had available.
Picture
A very happy Cal, checking out Scottish Wood - who supply us with sustainably sourced, locally grown wood for the project. This not for profit organization puts money back into making Scotland's woodlands more sustainable!


The final, but equally important reason for restoring Jameswood was because we love the character of the building, and we really feel it would be a shame to take down such a beautiful home.

Built in 1900, Jameswood is a lovely example of Victorian architecture. Her beautiful red sandstone face is a piece of Sandbank, as well as South west Scotland's history. The building is in keeping with the surrounding Victorian style architecture that dominates Dunoon, left from it's days as a seaside getaway from the hustle and bustle of life in Glasgow 120 years ago. 


Although Jameswood isn't a listed building, it stands 2nd in a row of 5 Victorian Red Sandstones. The council had made it clear that if we were to demolish, we would likely have to incorporate the red sandstone and some of the design features of the original building into our plans in order to get planning permission. Our tight budget wouldn't allow us to create the same character and beauty that is offered by Jameswood. Why take down a beautiful building to let a new build stand as a shadow of its former self? We didn't see the point of starting afresh. 


Picture
Cal and myself in front of Jameswood - our beautiful Victorian Villa.
Since we decided to embark on this journey, we haven't worried about whether we should have knocked it down and started over, or cut our loss and sold the building on. Those worries and what-ifs don't feel productive or helpful for the project.

Instead, our focus, from the very start, has been on moving forward. We focus, not on the problems that made people overlook this building for development, but on the solutions, that will help us bring the building back to life. 


So far, we are incredibly happy with our decision to restore. Will we still be so happy about our decision by the end of the project? I guess only time will tell, but until then, we will continue to try to learn and grow from the adventure presented to us. 

Thank you for following our journey, and for your incredible support along the way. Everyone's support has helped us immensely with our goal of saving Jameswood Villa. 

If you would like to support the Jameswood restoration project, you can visit our gofundme page at 
https://www.gofundme.com/f/whathavewedunoon, or you can follow our journey on Facebook or Instagram!

Thank you.

Sincerely,

Cal and Claire

Written by Claire Segeren 
​
Picture
Creative Commons License
What Have We Dunoon Blog by Claire Segeren is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Based on a work at whathavewedunoon.weebly.com.
55 Comments
Sarah Allen
9/1/2019 04:50:11 am

You 2 are setting great example in so many areas from self motivation, relationships, problem solving and my most favorite how to make the least environmental impact for your rebuild. Kudos to you both, may God bless you all many folds.

Reply
Heather
9/4/2019 09:50:43 am

I love your devotion to this project and that you want to be environmentally friendly. Thank you for these blog posts. Keep up the hard work! You're awesome!

Reply
Amy
9/10/2019 05:52:06 am

I couldn't love this project and the devotion the two of you have committed to it more! My grown children and ex-husband are all now following you as we all love reno work and history and Scotland. We are cheering you on from Oregon and Montana!
You both are incredible people and the world needs more like you ❤❤

Reply
Jeremy H
9/20/2019 06:16:54 am

You guys look like you're doing an amazing job! Nothing like being thrown into to the deep end to see if you'll sink or swim. But, like my mom always told me and my kin(2 brothers, 2 sisters) "You can do anything you put your mind to" keep up the awesome work! Best regards from this lumberjack in Michigan

Reply
Kathy Kaplan
9/26/2019 05:04:14 pm

This is your dream; follow it with your heart and soul. And don't ever let anyone tell you how "big" or "small" your dream should be. I happened to run into your story and felt very proud that you didn't let age, experience, or money get in your way. You go get 'em. I can't wait to see what is next for you. K from California

Reply
Toni-Marie Catchpaw
9/29/2019 11:20:04 am

Thank you for sharing your life adventure. Found your story mistakenly this morning. I will follow your adventures wherever they lead you, cheering you on every moment. Your enthusiasm has renewed my faith in accomplished dreams. Much Love 🕊️❤️🕊️

Reply
Christine M
10/10/2019 04:57:39 pm

I love following your progress! Your devotion to this wonderful building will yield years of love in a wonderful home!! Thank you for saving her!

Reply
Paul
11/7/2019 06:44:02 am

You two keep at it! Inspire, enjoy and appreciate every moment. Mutual hardship and growth make the best memories.

Reply
Jose albeiro link
12/27/2019 08:48:57 pm

Felicitaciones por favor no desfallecer en tan linda aventura, los admiro por su determinacion y espiritu de aventureros. Estare siguiendo su blog

Reply
Lisa Ellis
10/30/2020 09:18:16 am

I want to commend both of you on your dedication. It is so easy to tear down and build new. I love the charm and construction of the older buildings. They really don't build them like they used to. I also understand how daunting this project is as a whole. Keep looking at it one section at a time so it doesn't overwhelm and most importantly don't let it take you over as individuals and as a couple. I can see you even happier at the end of the project. Why? You can look at it and say look what we did!!

Reply
Mikel
12/7/2020 05:15:31 pm

You kids are the best. Your comprehension of Victorian-era building remodels will place you as top consultants in years to come. People like old stuff, AUTHENTIC stuff. If you refit others after this, become hoteliers and make a fortune from tourism [like Air BNB]. I see you as young, but really incredible at taking on responsibility, and 'load-balancing' under a giant task, as well as securing donations and sponsorships. Regards - Mikel from USA

Reply
Gallo
6/10/2021 10:49:23 pm

Přátelé.
Smekám před vámi svůj pomyslný klobouk a přeju vám hodně štěstí do budoucna a zároveň také i hodně zdaru k vaší fantastické práci kterou jste doposud odvedli. Good luck :-D

Reply
Bill Stange
6/11/2021 02:14:38 pm

I am 62 years old and have renovated 3 homes for my family in my lifetime. None as extensive as yours. I remember my first projects at your ages and am impressed how great a job you are doing together. My wife and I worked side by side just like you do. Be very proud of what you are doing. It will follow you for the rest of your lives.
Bill and Linda Wyoming, USA
Thank you for taking the time to share your story with us all.

Reply
Alec Shalinsky
8/8/2021 04:24:16 pm

Awesome project and many "shout outs". We embarked on a very similar project years ago (I'm 62 this year), and the house we started renovating was built in 1899 (Stratford, ON), and although not quite the same condition as yours it had many "features" that were like the analogy to an onion, "every time you pealed back a layer, it made you cry".
Copious amounts of cat pee, a fire in 1955 that few people new about, sagging floors, flooded basement, creosote retaining wall and every one telling us to demolish and rebuild. For the same reasons as you evaluated, we did not!
We too are restoring, aiming for EnerPhit level performance. Essentially building a house in a house. And BTW, we're not done yet either......
Good Luck and enjoy the adventure......

Reply
mobil ödeme bozdurma link
8/29/2022 01:54:59 pm

https://guvenbozum.com/

Reply
hacklink link
9/4/2022 07:39:01 am

Hacklink satın almak isteyenler için muhteşem bir site hacklink.gen.tr güçlü hacklink panel satışı ile sizde sıralamalarda yükseleceksiniz. Hemen sizde hacklink satın alın

Reply
site kurma link
9/11/2022 03:29:29 pm

Really informative article, I had the opportunity to learn a lot, thank you. https://kurma.website/

Reply
mobil ödeme bozdurma link
9/12/2022 12:54:38 am

Really informative article, I had the opportunity to learn a lot, thank you. https://odemebozdurma.com/

Reply
site kurma link
9/30/2022 04:12:08 am

It's great to have this type of content. Good luck with your spirit. Thank you. https://bit.ly/site-kurma

Reply
osmaniye escort link
10/4/2022 01:47:16 pm

I think this post is useful for people. It has been very useful for me. Looking forward to the next one, thank you. https://escortnova.com/escort-ilanlari/osmaniye-escort/

Reply
karatay escort link
10/5/2022 07:30:04 am

It was a post that I found very successful. Good luck to you. https://escortnova.com/escort-ilanlari/konya-escort/karatay-escort/

Reply
hanonu escort link
10/5/2022 03:15:30 pm

I follow your posts closely. I can find it thanks to your reliable share. Thank you. https://escortnova.com/escort-ilanlari/kastamonu-escort/hanonu-escort/

Reply
instagram takipçi satın al link
10/5/2022 11:47:54 pm

instagram takipçi satın almak ve arttırmak çok uygun hale geldi. Adresimiz dahilindeki bu fırsat ile istediğiniz sonuca ulaşabilirsiniz. Adresimiz bu alanda aktiftir.

Reply
iyidere escort link
10/6/2022 10:11:45 am

I support your continuation of your posts. I will be happy as new posts come. Thank you. https://escortnova.com/escort-ilanlari/rize-escort/iyidere-escort/

Reply
akhisar escort link
10/7/2022 04:41:19 am

I think the content is at a successful level. It adds enough information. Thank you. https://escortnova.com/escort-ilanlari/manisa-escort/akhisar-escort/

Reply
kepenk tamiri link
10/7/2022 05:17:29 am

istanbul kepenk tamiri sitesidir! Kepenk tamiri hizmetleri için ziyaret et! https://kepenktamiriistanbul.net/

Reply
talas escort link
10/7/2022 02:00:30 pm

Thank you for your sharing. I must say that I am successful in your content. https://escortnova.com/escort-ilanlari/kayseri-escort/talas-escort/

Reply
bayrampasa escort link
10/8/2022 07:39:26 am

Thoughtful and real content is shared. Thank you for these shares. https://escortnova.com/escort-ilanlari/istanbul-escort/bayrampasa-escort/

Reply
gentleherd code link
10/23/2022 02:13:06 am

Use Coupon Code to Get 35% Off Sitewide On Your Order at Gentle Herd. Coupons Tested Daily. You Save We Donate. 100% Verified. 100% Official & Verified. Huge Discounts. Coupons Tested Daily. 2023 TOP Coupon Codes.

Reply
korsan taksi link
11/11/2022 07:35:49 am

Hemen Göz At: https://taksikenti.com/

Reply
ledger live link
11/20/2022 04:43:08 am

Ledger Live : Most trusted & secure crypto wallet

Reply
evde iş imkanı link
11/21/2022 05:16:58 am

Sitemizi ziyaret et ve evden is imkanina bak: https://sites.google.com/view/evden-ek-is/

Reply
betinfo link
11/22/2022 07:56:38 pm

It was a successful post.These types of posts are very helpful.

Reply
mrbahis link
12/6/2022 07:03:22 pm

Congratulations for the successful article. I can't wait for the sequel.

Reply
mrbahis link
12/8/2022 02:54:00 pm

This is nice work. Seeing good works on good days gives one peace of mind.

Reply
takipçi satın al link
12/9/2022 05:36:02 am

Düşmeyen bot takipçi satın al: https://takipcialdim.com/

Reply
tiktok takipçi satın al link
12/9/2022 05:38:03 am

Tiktok takipçi satın almak için tıkla: https://takipcialdim.com/tiktok-takipci-satin-al/

Reply
instagram beğeni satın al link
12/9/2022 05:40:31 am

İnstagram beğeni takipçi satın al: https://takipcialdim.com/instagram-begeni-satin-al/

Reply
vbet link
12/9/2022 08:41:03 am

Congratulations, it's a nice post. I'm always waiting for such nice posts in the future.

Reply
takipçi satın al link
12/15/2022 05:10:40 am

uygun fiyatlardan takipçi Hemen Göz At: https://takipcim.com.tr/

Reply
sms onay link
12/15/2022 05:12:14 am

Tıkla: https://www.smsonay.com/

Reply
casino siteleri link
12/27/2022 05:42:22 pm

online casino oyna: http://haikuboy.com

Reply
https://www.anabolickapinda14.com/urun/ link
4/27/2023 04:55:00 pm

Steroid Sipariş: https://www.anabolickapinda14.com/urun/

Reply
test click link
4/28/2023 02:06:19 am

Le sujet dont vous parlez dans votre message offre une nouvelle perspective. Les nouvelles idées que vous avez fournies m'ont beaucoup intéressé. Passer le test du clic est un excellent moyen de vous mettre au défi et d'améliorer votre concentration. Vous pouvez améliorer vos compétences de clic grâce à la pratique, ce qui peut être utile dans de nombreuses sphères de la vie.

Reply
heets fiyatları link
5/10/2023 10:10:53 am

Heets Siparişi Ver: https://bit.ly/heets-heets

Reply
iqos heets link
5/12/2023 08:29:04 am

Heets satın al iqos heets: https://bit.ly/heets-heets

Reply
Winstrol satın al link
5/22/2023 09:45:01 am

Winstrol satın al: steroidsatinal.org

Reply
https://steroidvip5.com/ link
8/9/2023 06:41:57 am

Steroid Siparis Steroid Fiyatlari Steroidler Anabolizan Orjinal Steroid Steroid Satis Steroid Satın Al Steroid Siparis Et

Reply
https://peptidci.com/ link
10/22/2023 07:51:51 am

Tıkla: https://peptidci.com/

Reply
sms onay link
2/4/2024 04:54:48 am

Sitemizi ziyaret et: SMS Onay Sepeti

Reply
먹튀검증 link
3/12/2025 08:31:16 am

That appears to be excellent however i am still not too sure that I like it. At any rate will look far more into it and decide personally!

Reply
먹튀검증 link
3/12/2025 08:46:21 pm

This content is written very well. Your use of formatting when making your points makes your observations very clear and easy to understand. Thank you.

Reply
파타야 가라오케 link
3/25/2025 09:49:54 pm

I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.

Reply
나트랑 가라오케 link
3/28/2025 05:57:59 am

Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Big thanks for the useful info.

Reply
esportiva vet link
5/3/2025 05:01:33 am

Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post with people..

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    May 2023
    January 2023
    June 2022
    March 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    November 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Support
  • Contact